It’s understandable if you want all-around footwear that you can use for different settings and purposes. That’s practical and more cost-efficient.
A high-quality pair of boots – one that is sturdy enough to protect you well in the workplace and is comfortable enough for long hikes on the trail – is a very good example of this.
But is that advisable?
It’s perfectly all right to use a nice pair of leather boots for both working and hiking in certain situations. However, there is a sound reason why manufacturers make an industrial pair and another one for trail use, making the materials used and the manner of construction completely different for each.
There are several points wherein these two specific types of footwear vary. Lucky you, we’re listing everything below:
Part of the Shoe Covered: Outsole
The traction is defined as the grip or adhesion of the outsole – the bottom (usually) rubber part of the boot – on the floor, soil, or any terrain.
The lug soles of both hike and work boots are thick, heavy, and features deep indents for better friction with the ground. But when you look at each closely, you will see that the pattern of the indentations is very different from each other.
- For workers’ footwear, the indents are squarer and evenly lined on the surface of the ball and the heel parts. The arch is usually left flat.
- On the other hand, hikers’ variants have oddly-shaped indentations (rhombuses, quadrilaterals, trapezoids, isosceles triangles, and scalenes, just to name a few) all over the sole. The arch also has ovoid patches over it.
The Reason for the Difference:
- The former has a more uniform layout because most workplaces have smooth or at least a more even flooring or ground.
- The latter’s odd outsole design provides the necessary traction in the uneven grounds of mountains and other trekking fields.
Other boot collections:
2. Level of Protection
There are several ways in which manufacturers add protective features to their footwear. Although hiking shoes have some of these, the ones for work are more beefed up because safety is a must-have in certain industries.
2a – Component Involved: Toe Protection
Industrial shoes have a layer of steel (aptly called ‘steel toe’) or tough resin over the toes to prevent injuries in case something falls on the feet – a common cause of injury in construction, electrical, and mining sites, just to name a few.
The ones for trekking do not have this for two main reasons: 1) it’s will make the shoes heavier and 2) it’s going to make the shoes stiff and uncomfortable – both a no-no for long, challenging hikes.
2b – Component Involved: Ankle Support
This particular feature can be seen in both boot types because the activities these are meant for involves a whole lot of standing and walking.
But special materials and construction are used for trekking footwear so that the cuffs will be high, soft, breathable, and flexible. In comparison, industrial boots just have stiff uppers and thick laces so that the tops can be laced tight.
2c – Component Involved: Waterproofing
Work and hike don’t stop with a little bit (or, at times, a whole lot) of rain. A sturdy raincoat and a pair of well-made shoes allow you to do these tasks comfortably.
Certain kinds of leather, on their own, have a level of water resistance. Many manufacturers of industrial boots rely on that, merely fortifying it with water-repellent solutions or sprays.
But that doesn’t mean you can dip your shoes in a deep puddle and expect your feet to be dry.
High-quality trail boots have one or more layers of waterproofing. Gore-Tex, for instance, sews a special bootie over the insole so that water won’t touch your toes.
2d – Component Involved: Oil and Slip Resistance
Oil, chemicals, and other spills are expected (but aimed to be prevented) in construction, mining, and similar work sites, that is why industrial boots have this feature more than trekking boots.
Part of the Shoe Covered: Uppers and Insoles
Breathability refers to the ability of the material to absorb the moisture from the inside (aka your foot’s sweat) and then vent it out to the outer shell of the shoe.
This feature is so important to hefty and dense footwear like boots, particularly when it’s something which you will be wearing for a long period. And the noted tasks in this article require you to wear those shoes for eight hours or more.
Both trail and industrial boots have different levels of breathability that, to be honest, depend more on the brand than on the type.
4. Durability in Different Terrains
This feature refers to how durable the shoe is in various terrains – sandy deserts, rocky hills and mountains, soft marshes, wet rivers, and so on.
By just comparing the two, it’s easier to lean towards industrial boots as the more durable option. Thicker, sturdier, heavier, and packed with various protective features, this can handle a whole lot of abuse. However, those may not last long when it is used in other terrains – especially in rocky mountainous ones or wet, muddy spots.
On the other hand, trekking shoes do not have enough protection that is required in PPEs (Personal Protective Equipment) required in industrial workplaces.
Flexibility is defined as the quality of bending without breaking. Certain types must have this while others should be rigid for protection.
- Trail shoes, based on many of the features mentioned above, are more flexible than the ones for industrial use.
- The other type should be flexible inside so that your feet are comfortable. But the outer components must be rigid so that when you accidentally step on a nail, it doesn’t go all the way in and puncture your foot.
The former is made of softer materials that target comfort for long-distance walks rather than substantial protection. The latter’s rigidity, on the other hand, is not made for extended standing or walking. Again, it is included in the design as protection.
6. Overall Weight
Again, just based on what has been already mentioned, work boots are heavier than the ones for trekking.
The thick outer leather, lug soles made from heavy rubber, steel toes, and other protective features, make that type incredibly heavy. On average, one can weigh up to 4.5 pounds (2 kilos). The other type generally comes in at 2 pounds (nearly 1 kilogram) – just half of what the first one weighs.
7. Overall Comfort
As we have been discussing over and over, the ones for hiking provide more comfort. These are made for long-distance walks over hard, rocky terrain and muddy or wet spots.
Any miner or construction worker will tell you that it’s difficult to wear industrial footwear for eight hours. In fact, they will only wear these when they’re asked to go on the field then change to more comfortable ones when they’re in the office.
Hiking shoes, with all their features and overall look, are more versatile. Some even wear these in their workplace, especially when they’re not in dangerous or high-risk areas because these provide a good level of protection from nature and are comfortable. These also look better when worn casually, with jeans and a shirt.
Is It Possible to Find the Perfect Pair?
(With All the Features Noted)
Yes. With so many manufacturing companies, you can definitely find the perfect pair. Here are some of the brands considered as the best:
- Timberland’s Pro Bosshog with Carbon Shield toe protection
- Skechers’ Tarlac Steel Toe
- Caterpillar’s Second Shift Steel Toe
- Under Armour’sValsetz RTS (with side zipper and plastic toe cap)
- Wolverine’s Durashocks(with steel and soft toe options)
You would notice that all of these have toe caps, one of the most important features in a pair of industrial boots. Many of these are relatively lightweight as well – a great feature for those who hate to lug their feet around.
- Salomon’s X Ultra GTX (or with Gore-Tex waterproof technology)
- Merrel’s Moab 2 (M Select DRY waterproof technology)
- Danner’s Mountain WP (Danner Dry waterproof technology)
- La Sportiva’s Pyramid GTX
- Scarpa’s Zodiac Plus GTX
A lot of these pairs invested in waterproof and sweat-wicking technology because comfort is possibly the number one must-have in this type of footwear.
The Best Advice: Use the Proper Footwear
If you work in any of the industries mentioned above and like outdoor activities such as camping and trekking, you should get one of each.
Sure, in certain situations, it’s OK to use just one pair for both tasks. But you’ll soon find out this won’t work.
Imagine walking around for just an hour in heavy, steel-toe work boots. And, even if you’re allowed by your company to wear trail shoes as your PPE, would you really risk the possibility of stepping on something sharp?
A pair of high-quality ones can be quite expensive at $200 or more. But protecting your feet – the foundation of your body – is an investment. Get both. It’s worth it!
Steve Oddvar Vicantas is a professional electrician and building inspector who loves writing about work boots, work safety, and everything in between. He is also a part-time blogger when he has spare time.